07
May
unnamed (1)

Earlier today we posted on a new version of RBI Baseball for Android. You know what, I'm just going to recommend you read that story instead. Go ahead, close this tab and read the story about the premium baseball game with decades of history and no in-app purchases. It's OK. I won't feel bad. Just go.

unnamed (2)

Still with me? OK. MLB Perfect Inning is a high-end baseball sim from Gamevil. In addition to some very impressive graphics and and the licensed likenesses of over 200 Major League Baseball players, it features motion capture from real-life pitchers and catchers. Players and stadiums are rendered in detail, or at least enough detail that it's appealing while still being playable by most recent Android phones and tablets. The player models look like they're at about Dreamcast level, and the interface has been modified to allow for more pitching and batting decisions, even on a touchscreen.

unnamed (4) unnamed unnamed (3)

Most of the features from a console-style baseball game are present, including all-star recruiting, drafts and trades, and a full season mode. And because baseball is an inherently slow sport and mobile games need to be limber, players will have the option of speeding up games with a variety of play styles, including full manual, offense only, a highlights-only mode, and full AI, where your team plays for you. Which I guess is more of a screensaver than a game. Multiplayer is limited to leaderboards.

Dedicated Android gamers know what's coming next. This is a Gamevil game, which means that it's free, and it also means that there's a massive upsell. Sure enough, Perfect Inning uses the somewhat manipulative dual-currency system for "leveling up" players and facilitating drafts and trades. If that wasn't enough, it's also got a time-based element - your players will get low on stamina and require a recharge or time on the bench to get back to full strength. I suppose that stamina and money are both parts of real baseball, so the tired in-app purchase model makes a little bit of in-universe sense.

2014-05-07 15.24.29 2014-05-07 15.24.06 2014-05-07 15.24.12

What doesn't make sense is this warning in the app description: "MLB Perfect Inning will need permission to access your phone numbers within your phone. The information collected will only be used within the game. The data collected is encrypted and will not be shared with others."Hey Gamevil, what possible reason could a baseball game have for taking a peek at my phone book? Just asking.

Seriously, go check out RBI Baseball instead.

Update: A Gamevil representative contacted us after reading this article, stating that the collection of phone numbers is required for Gamevil's South Korean players (Gamevil's corporate headquarters are in Seoul), and the company hasn't been able to remove the data collection from the international release. The representative noted that they're working on a way to remove it for international players.

Michael Crider
Michael is a native Texan and a former graphic designer. He's been covering technology in general and Android in particular since 2011. His interests include folk music, football, science fiction, and salsa verde, in no particular order.

  • Jephri

    Always thought it was funny that EVIL in all caps is part of their name.

  • EyeCorporations

    The game also yells at you for "unlawful activity" and doesn't let you play if you're rooted.

    • WhoaManWtF

      It worked fine for me... Anytime any game or app that I didn't get for root purpose ask for root I just DENY it, seems to work on pretty much everything including this game... Why would you give this game root permission to your device anyways?

      • EyeCorporations

        Of course I didn't give it root permission, it shouldn't even be asking nor refusing to let me play.

        • WhoaManWtF

          Weird.. I don't understand why it works for me then, all I did was deny it.. The only thing I could think is maybe you have a cheat app installed on your phone? One of those apps that is designed to edit these kind of games and steal the premium currency? I had a popup similar to that back when I had GameCIH installed on my device.

    • sy

      Agree. I just tried and it did not work. I even denied superuser and nothing worked. O well at least I didn't waste my time with it.

  • flonker

    Thank you for this review. I am so tired of far too many people being accepting of unneeded permissions and the scam that is the free-to-play model.

    • Tomasz Kuczynski

      First time my wife touched my tablet she tried to install facebook and being an iOS user she read through the permissions of the app carefully and used the browser instead because "there is no reason why facebook should look at my contacts, know my location, ... ".

  • merman1983

    I was a fan of the Baseball Superstars games for several years and then the in-app nagging and "pay to win" crap just went to a new level in the last version I tried (2013 I remember). I remember it both having a problem with me being rooted and then it requested root access to my phone. Uninstalled and I've not gone back since. I have missed having a decent Baseball game on my phone, but there's nothing I've found that I like (and RBI is incompatible with my GNex)

  • Will

    This game is really good. After playing this I realized they could make a console game for us Xbox Owners which would be wicked awesome!!

  • Kevin McCarty

    I use a hack for MLB Perfect Ining that gave me unlimited gold and stars. Here it is: http://g4mehacks.com/mlb-perfect-inning-hack/