19
Nov
wm_IMG_2206

The HTC One X was (and still is) a fantastic device thanks to its solid hardware, excellent build quality, and stunning display. But it's a little long in the tooth, partially because the newest high-end smartphones have both quad-core CPUs and LTE, and partially because in the smartphone world, anything that's 7 months old is (unfortunately) outdated.

That brings us to the HTC One X+, which is more of a mid-cycle refresh than an all-new model. It keeps the same basic frame and the outstanding display, but packs a more powerful version of NVIDIA's quad-core Tegra 3 CPU, and the AT&T variant even comes with LTE. HTC has also upped the battery capacity and doubled the maximum storage, to 64GB. The outstanding (and indestructible) polycarbonate body is now rubberized, so it's grippier and much more attractive.

wm_IMG_2195

They may be minor changes, but the sum of the parts makes a great phone even better.

The Specs

  • Price: $200 on contract, $550 retail
  • Availability: November 15, 2012 (Europe), November 16, 2012 (US, AT&T)
  • CPU: 1.7GHz NVIDIA Tegra 3 CPU (AP37)
  • Memory: 1GB DDR3 RAM, 64GB storage 
  • Display: 4.7" SuperLCD 2 @ 1280 x 720
  • Camera: 8MP rear, 1.6MP front
  • Battery: 2100mAh
  • OS: Android 4.1 (Jelly Bean) with Sense 4+ UI
  • Connectivity: 802.11a/b/g/n, Bluetooth 4.0, HSPA+, LTE (AT&T)
  • Dimensions: 134.36 x 69.9 x 8.9mm, 135 grams

The Good

  • The same display was outstanding on the One X, and it's just as outstanding here. In fact, I can't think of a single shortcoming with it. It's bright, crisp, and colors are great. What's not to love?
  • The build is amazing. They took the virtually indestructible polycarbonate of the original and rubberized it. If nuclear war broke out, only cockroaches and HTC One X(+)s would be left - but the plusses would feel fantastic to the touch.
  • As speedy and smooth as can be. Granted, I feel like just about every new Android device is snappy thanks to the current crop of processors and the polish of Android 4.0/4.1/4.2, but the point remains that even with all the bloat from Sense, every action is instant.
  • Excluding the red capacitive buttons, it looks excellent. Between the matte rubberized coating that seems to absorb all the light in the area and the red accents, it just looks downright sinster.
  • Sense 4+ offers a few seriously great features, such as the quick camera startup and burst mode. Plus, it's better for the non-techies.

The Bad

  • Sense 4+ is bloated and ugly-ish. It's good for some people (read: my tech-challenged mother), but not for me. It also replaces some stock Android apps (such as Gallery) with crappy HTC versions.

Deep Dive

Build quality

wm_IMG_2190

The build quality of the One X is excellent - worlds better than any other Android devices on the market. With the One X+, HTC has kicked it up a notch further. It retains the indestructible polycarbonate body, but it has now gained a rubberized coating. Not only does that improve feel and durability, but it's much more attractive and stylish than the original. Calling the finish matte is an understatement - it's almost a light-consuming black that's broken only by the red accents around the camera, for the Beats logo, and on the capacitive touch keys. In fact, the only weak spot to the appearance is that the deep red color of the capacitive touch buttons just feels like a bit too much; that said, I can't think of any other color that would work, so take that minor complaint with a grain of salt.

wm_IMG_2197 wm_IMG_2199

A quick run-around of the features on the phone: the camera and LED flash are centered along the back near the top, and flanked by the microSIM slot, power button, and headphone jack on the top side. The pogo pins are aligned vertically on the back along the right side. Finally, the microUSB port is on the upper left side, and the volume controls are on the upper right side.

Strictly speaking, it may not be the the most fashionable phone, but I can't think of another device that comes close in terms of sheer toughness and yet remains attractive. Plus, it feels great to hold thanks to the just-right weight and soft, grippy finish.

Display

wm_IMG_2208

Reviewers have universally praised the display of the One X, and it remains one of (if not the) best displays ever put on a smartphone. Sharpness is class-leading, color quality is spot-on, brightness is excellent even in direct sunlight, and viewing angles are on par with printed textbooks. The sole characteristic that isn't class-leading is the black levels, and even then, they're still very good.

wm_IMG_2210 wm_IMG_2211 wm_IMG_2212

In short, HTC has made precisely zero changes to the display from the HTC One X, and for very good reason: because it's absolutely outstanding.

Performance & Battery Life

wm_IMG_2207

Performance is excellent on the One X+, but as I said above, that shouldn't come as much of a surprise. The Tegra 3 coupled with Ice Cream Sandwich already kept things smooth as butter on the One X, and with the X+ packing an even faster CPU and more optimized version of Android, things are better than ever. Apps open extremely quickly and actions execute speedily. In fact, the only thing that seems to bog things down (albeit very, very rarely) is Sense's tips widget. Frankly, that's an issue with the software (Sense), not with the hardware.

 Screenshot_2012-11-18-08-48-10 Screenshot_2012-11-18-10-17-26 Screenshot_2012-11-18-08-46-56

Battery life is good. Certainly at the upper end of what's to be expected from a smartphone, but nothing outstanding. For example, I got about 22 hours out of it with moderate use (browsing, social networking, calling, texting, and YouTube). That's very good, but with heavy use the battery drops rather quickly. Odds are good you'll make it through the day without a concern.

Software

Screenshot_2012-11-17-09-28-13 Screenshot_2012-11-17-09-27-50 Screenshot_2012-11-17-09-28-03

Note the Holo blue at the bottom...

Though it has its merits, Sense is, unfortunately, as obtrusive as ever. And where it used to be my favorite UI in the pre-Ice Cream Sandwich days, it's fallen out of favor since. Android used to be ugly and jerky, so it was understandable that HTC would slap a skin on top of it. But since ICS - and especially now, with jelly Bean - Android has a clear and attractive visual style, with performance to match. Sense, on the other hand, is uglier than ever in virtually every respect.

Screenshot_2012-11-17-09-27-34 Screenshot_2012-11-17-09-27-43 Screenshot_2012-11-17-15-29-18

Huge widgets everywhere by default, though the pointers widget (center) is pretty useful. The notification shade fills up very quickly.

Where to begin? The lock screen, while functional, is extremely ugly. The widgets are huge and bloated, which is annoying since they could easily be 1/4 of the size and still accomplish just as much. Worst of all, the entire color scheme - which used to have a fairly cohesive system of greys and green - now has a touch of Holo blue. That's good in theory, but unfortunately, stupidly executed. Because now, instead of uniformity, we have a mix of the old standard green accents, mingled with the new holo blue accents. You know what clashes? Pale Holo blue and vibrant Sense green. Maybe I'm being extra critical because I ran vanilla Android 4.1.2 on my One X, so I'm accustomed to how beautiful Holo was on its own, but make up your own mind:

Screenshot_2012-11-18-15-44-08 Screenshot_2012-11-18-15-44-33

"That color scheme is beautiful!" said no one, ever.

In short, Sense is more visually bloated and confused than ever. That's not to say it's terrible, or even bad - but HTC has remained largely stationary over the years, while Google has moved forward by leaps and bounds. What was once an improvement is now another straw on the camel's back.

Screenshot_2012-11-17-09-27-16 Screenshot_2012-11-17-11-48-48

As I alluded above, there are a few bright spots with Sense. First, the camera is great from a software standpoint. It loads very quickly and is extremely fast to take shots. The burst mode is awesome, as is the ability to take photos while recording videos. I also love that the lockscreen music widget works with more than just HTC's music player. I can control Google Music without having to unlock my device - a nice perk, since I stream music while driving.

All that said, there's a key fact here that must be emphasized: although stock Android is absolutely fantastic, it's not something the average middle-aged Joe could pick up and use intuitively; Sense is. It's fatter and stupider, and that's what non-techies need. So while I hate it for myself, I like it for, say, my mother. (Though I'd love if they would make it optional and satisfy both of us...)

Camera

wm_IMG_2200

The camera is a really mixed bag. It opens very quickly and snaps photos instantly, so it's fantastic for catching a moment. The colors are vibrant and without zooming in, the images look fantastic. Low-light performance is also good considering we're talking about a tiny phone camera, though. That's probably in part due to HTC's whole "5 levels of flash brightness" thing.

 IMAG0005 IMAG0006

The left is with HDR mode, the right is regular.

IMAG0002 IMAG0010

The photo on the right was taken in a very dark room -the flash provided the only illumination.

That said, pictures are extremely grainy when zoomed in. At 75% it's bad, and at 100% it's awful. As Jean-Baptiste Quéru correctly pointed out, we don't really need a high-MP camera putting out huge images. It's really better to just focus on the image quality.

Still, let's be honest: scale down the pictures to any size that fits on your monitor, and they'll look very good. And given that it's a phone camera, the intention should really be to capture an unexpected moment, not photograph a wedding. With that scope in mind, the One X+ is well-suited thanks to the quick launch-and-shoot times and image quality that's good when scaled to fit your monitor/TV.

Conclusion

wm_IMG_2202 wm_IMG_2205

I play with a ton of phones - far more than I review. I almost always have at least one loaner phone around, and sometimes as many as three. It's sounds silly, but getting my hands on every damn piece of tech (usually Android, but sometimes the competition, too) is the best way for me to produce reliable, honest reviews. With that in mind, the original HTC One X is the best all-around phone I've ever used (though I have yet to lay hands on the Optimus G/Nexus 4).

wm_IMG_2198

Or rather, it was - now that crown goes to the One X+. And how could it not, really? It looks and feels better than the original, packs more power (and 4G), and runs a more optimized version of Android. It's not perfect, but it's still an excellent device.

Aaron Gingrich
Aaron is a geek who has always had a passion for technology. When not working or writing, he can be found spending time with his family, playing a game, or watching a movie.

  • megalyte

    Great Review, any chance for a AT&T version review?

    • http://www.androidpolice.com/ Cameron Summerson

      It's the same phone, the AT&T version just has LTE and a slightly different color scheme.

      • megalyte

        Fair enough, I think that AT&T's version looks better though.

      • White Pawn

        I believe that could affect the 'battery life' part of your review though.

  • http://twitter.com/nastybutler77 Jameson Ahern

    I'm debating between the 1X+ and the Optimus G (no N4 due to puny storage capacity). I think I'll wait until you get a chance to compare the two for us.

  • http://twitter.com/A2Eric Eric S

    Is it possible to unlock the bootloader for root and getting rid of Sense?

    • nicooo

      Bootloader unlock: check. Root: check. Getting rid of sense: too early. Wait a few weeks until CM10 is ported.

      • Jeremiah

        Bootloader unlock and root on the AT&T version?

  • Mco

    You know I actually find the One X+ to be a much "prettier" device than the Droid DNA..the latter comes off to me as gaudy attempting to be cool. The X+ is more understated and much better looking.

    • Luis Augusto Fretes Cuevas

      The front of the DNA is rather ugly, and the One X is gorgeous, the thing is... the white One X was prettier and didn't have those awful absurd red capacitive buttons.

  • White Pawn

    Thanks for the great review!

    It would be great if we can have a comparison between the Optimus G and the One X+, though.

    By the way, everywhere I find the two phones compared, reviewers soon switch to comparing the software - the custom software skin LG and HTC have on these phones, respectively. However, it is important to note though, that many of us actually end up using custom ROMs, such as Cyanogenmod, on our phones anyway. Sure, the ROMs may not be out yet because both phones are just released, but when they are, I am sure many of us will ditch the manufacturer skins. For quicker updates, if not for anything else.

    So, I guess what I am trying to request is, please have a comparison between the two phones, and it would be great if you can keep the hardware and software comparisons as separate as possible, so that everybody benefits.

  • Aakaash Bali

    Can someone comment on the audio quality, compared to the S4 HOXL? I know that the T3 DAC has gotten a rather bad reputation lately, I'm hoping this was fixed. I do wish this had the built in amplifier on the headphone jack like the DNA as.

    • http://www.androidpolice.com/ David Ruddock

      As far as I can tell it's the same headphone amp that's in the regular Tegra 3 One X.

    • Frank

      even though it's the same headphone amp, GSMArena has said the audio has improved from the original HOX (Tegra 3 version). Although there is still some hiss and the volume still isn't very loud, they found there was much less distortion compared to the original Tegra 3 HOX.

      So although the headphone amp may be the same something the audio may well be slightly better quality than the original HOX.

  • UtopiaNH

    My old atrix just broke on friday, and they are 'early upgrading' me, and I had to impulse decide on friday and picked the Galaxy S3 over this. Now I'm not so sure. Now, from a longevity standpoint, is the dual core snapdragon and 2 gigs of ram, or the quad tegra and 1 gig of ram going to /last longer/ for me? From a decision standpoint, I care very little about screen quality (I didn't even notice the much derided Atrix screen was pentile til I read about it), and the removable battery and 2 gigs of ram swayed me to the GS3. I find both touchwiz and sense abhorrent but couldn't wait weeks for a phone. The build quality on this definitely seems good physically, but so was the Atrix 4G and I had the radio die on it after only a year and three months. So, which do you think is more likely to last the 1.5 years I need between upgrades? (Of note, I didn't realize on friday that GS3 on AT&T didn't have Jellybean yet, but I do believe it's got a ton of ROM support?)

    • Bryan Cantos

      You should also consider the Optimus G while you're at it.

      • UtopiaNH

        It's hardware seems viable but I've heard nothing but terrible and consistent issues with longevity on their phones (they break more.) and are also the least updated. I'm not even certain I am going to root my phone.

        I also didn't see it on the at&t website with the others, though I didn't intentionally look at it.

  • Samik Parekh

    I am looking forward to root my AT&T one x+ and put CM10 on it... Any one knows how to root

  • http://profiles.google.com/diegopadron05 Diego Padron

    HTC needs to get its shit together and bring the One X line to T-Mobile

  • http://www.facebook.com/xmokuro Ahmed Alzahrani

    "The Tegra 3 coupled with Ice Cream Sandwich already kept things smooth as butter..."

    Jelly Bean you mean ;)

    • AaronGingrich

      When I reviewed the One X, it was running ICS :)

  • Petr Plachý

    Well I like my Sense gallery :P

  • http://www.facebook.com/lucyparanormal Daniel Tiberius

    Looking forward to your Nexus 4 review!

  • Lennart

    What about the Camera nipple? I have a HTC One X and even though its only 2 months old and has been handled with the utmost care It sports a few scratches on the camera Lens.

  • Melo

    I thought this was a One X+ review, not a soapbox for sense-bashing. We get it- you don't like sense.

  • Neil

    I love this phone. The design is even better than other phones like the gs3 and the size is just right for me. but the problem is i've seen drop tests of the htc one x, and it wasnt that good. I was just wondering if the htc one x+ is more durable than the one x. I also do not want to go for the s3 because of the same problem. But I love the features on the gs3.. But I really wanted a one x+.