29
Oct

Touchscreens have allowed a whole new era of innovation in mobile gaming and so far it's been pretty great. Sometimes, though, you just need buttons. There are a variety of companies out there trying to create the right solution and this isn't even the first review I've done on a third-party controller. With a unique grip to hold your smartphone, though, this one actually seemed like it stood a fighting chance of not disappearing into the nearest drawer. Of course, hardware is rarely the real problem for Android controllers, is it? But let's not get ahead of ourselves.

The Good

  • Decent size. Not unusably tiny like most third-party controllers. Could be a bit bigger, but most people won't have a problem.
  • Can hold most phones. Short of a Note, just about any large-screened phone will be held snugly in the flip-up grip.
  • Good build quality. Given the price, it's nice to know this thing isn't cheaply built.
  • Faux leather carrying case is a nice touch.

The Bad

  • Incredibly sparse list of supported apps. Even if you own games that work with the controller, they may not work if you didn't buy them through the right channels.
  • Sync software is buggy and disconnects frequently if you're not in-game. This doesn't interfere with playing, but does make it very difficult to jump out to check a message real quick.
  • At $50, the price is pretty steep for what you get. This could be improved if the connection software is fixed and if more developers pick up the platform, but as of right now, it doesn't look too robust.

Hardware

 

Let's start with the build quality. It's fantastic. Opening a $50 game controller that's not from Sony, Microsoft or Nintendo can be a harrowing experience. At that price, the bar is set pretty high, but the track record for accessories of this caliber isn't great. Rest assured though, the MOGA hardware is wonderful. While a little tiny for my tastes, the device is very sturdy.

The controller has plenty of buttons to handle just about any game you could throw at it. Two control sticks, four regular buttons (traditional A, B, X, Y), start, select, and two trigger buttons. There are also two more controls for syncing the device via Bluetooth: a hardware switch sits underneath the flip-up phone holder, which ensures that you won't drain the battery when the device is off, and a second button that is used for pairing.

The flip-up phone holder is particularly nice. This controller allows you to place your phone in an expandable grip. I was able to fit a few different phones in it including my Galaxy Nexus, though a device as large as the Galaxy Note might be a bit of a stretch. The entire piece of hardware is very impressive and felt like something I really wanted to play with. As a bit of icing on the cake, the package even came with a faux leather carrying case. It's a great touch.

moga2  

Software

Unfortunately, as much as I absolutely adore the hardware, that's about where the whirlwind romance ends. The big hang up with any accessory like this is the software. It doesn't matter how great the design is if you can't play anything with it. There are a few different reasons why this thing falls short, so let me go through them one at a time.

The MOGA Pivot App

2012-10-29 19.17.59 2012-10-29 19.18.06 2012-10-29 19.18.15

The first thing you'll need to do in order to connect the controller is install the MOGA Pivot app. Requiring an app to sync an accessory and your phone isn't unprecedented. Where this one fails, though, is that apparently if you leave the app, the link is broken. It's not a huge problem except that it's rather annoying to get a notification that the MOGA is missing every time you respond to a text or check your email. The shade spam is made even worse due to the fact that the Pivot app is persistent. The only way I found to close the app and, in doing so, get rid of the ongoing notification, was to force close it.

To clarify, this bizarre notification spam occurs before you actually enter a game. The Pivot app isn't just a background process that handles the communication between the accessory and the phone. It's also a middle man for game sales. This is the second area where the app has major problems. While you can't actually buy games via MOGA (the Play Store doesn't allow distribution of other app stores), it does serve to connect you with games you can use the controller with.

2012-10-29 19.18.21 2012-10-29 19.18.27 2012-10-29 19.20.59

The problem is, only some of the games are linked by the Play Store. Particularly some Gameloft apps, which can be among the more expensive titles on Android, are actually purchased via the company's own site. You download the APKs directly and only when you install via this method will the controller work. To test this, I acquired Dungeon Hunter 3 from Google's market. The MOGA wouldn't respond at all.

Apparently the controller only works if the game you want to play was purchased or installed via whatever method Pivot chooses. If it links to the Play Store entry, then your previous install should work just fine. The titles that are acquired via independent distribution will need to be repurchased and, obviously, won't be tied to your Google account.

2012-10-29 19.18.58 2012-10-29 19.19.11 2012-10-29 19.19.46

This is a very big usability problem. If you've already bought certain titles from the Play Store, you can't use this accessory without buying them again. If you haven't already got them, then you can spend the money, but they might not be tied to your Google account. Lose the APK and you're on your own.

For what it's worth, the controller comes with two free titles. Pac-man, which normally costs $4 in the Pivot app as of this writing, and a code for a copy of Sonic CD. Both are in MOGA's faux storefront and both are great classics. Unfortunately, they're not $50 worth of fun. Beyond those, the selection is extremely meager. There are a mere 21 apps in the supported list, two of which are the aforementioned gratis games, three more are free versions of other paid entries, and only 6 others are just plain free. While you have at least a few options, you could still sink a lot of money into a very isolated and sparsely populated ecosystem.

Here is the full list of titles available at the time of writing:

  • Asphalt 7: Heat
  • Doom GLES
  • Dungeon Hunter 3
  • Final Freeway 2R
  • Galaxy NGC3D HD
  • Gangstar Rio: City of Saints
  • GnarBike Trials
  • GnarBike Trials Pro
  • N.O.V.A. 3
  • PAC-MAN
  • Real Soccer 2013
  • Riptide GP
  • Rocket Fox
  • Six-Guns
  • Sky Gamblers
  • Sonic The Hedgehog 4 - Episode II
  • Stealth Chopper 3D
  • Stealth Chopper Demo
  • The Dark Knight Rises
  • Virtua Tennis Challenge
  • Virtua Tennis Challenge Free

Gameplay

Once you've decided how to get your games, the experience is actually pretty great. Controls are very responsive. There was virtually zero lag at all, even while playing games like Sonic CD, which generally rely on fast reactions. Once you're playing, the connection between the controller and the phone is steady. Head to the homescreen, though, and the connection will be broken soon, and it's a bit of a pain to get back into the app.

As I mentioned earlier, the size of the controller is substantially nicer than many others like it, however for some reason, the MOGA is still a bit tinier than is comfortable, and I don't have above average-sized hands. Perhaps this might be more comfortable for a kid, however as far back as the NES, gamepads have been designed that fit both adult and children's hands. The reason for why these things keep getting manufactured a bit smaller than is comfortable is a mystery. All that being said, fat fingers should be wary.

Conclusion

As Android gaming accessories go, this is still one of the best I've used. It's small, but not cripplingly so, the hardware is solidly built, and it's designed to actually hold your phone, solving the awkward usability problem of most Bluetooth controllers. However, the software really makes it difficult to love. Personally, I'm very uncomfortable buying games via developers' websites and losing the ability to sync with my Google account. Even if that's not a concern for you, though, the positively abysmal selection of games makes spending $50 on buttons a questionable choice.

The upside is, MOGA at least seems to be well-connected (pun cruelly intended). You don't get official support from titles Pac-Man or Sonic without having at least some weight behind your product. However, I'd still at least like to see all games you've previously purchased from the Play Store be compatible, not just the ones that the Pivot app doesn't distribute directly via publishers.

It's hard to give a glowing recommendation to this controller, but if you really want to do some gaming with buttons, and Pac-Man, Sonic CD, and Gameloft get you excited, then the experience will be well worth your money. If you just want to buy a gamepad and see what's available, you might want to hold off. Hopefully MOGA will fix some of the bugginess of the app, and improve compatibility with games you've already purchased. Until then, though, be sure that the selection of titles is worth it up front.

Eric Ravenscraft
Eric is a snarky technophile with a taste for the unusual. When he's not obsessing about Android, you can usually find him obsessing about movies, psychology, or the perfect energy drink. Eric weaves his own special blend of snark, satire, and comedy into all his articles.

  • bitbank

    This is the tradeoff hardware manufacturers have to make when deciding what bluetooth protocols to support. If they support HID keyboard mode, then many apps can use the controls, but they don't have any control over the use of the controller - it's just another bluetooth keyboard. I will be receiving mine tomorrow and aim to reverse engineer the bluetooth connection. I've done it for other controllers and it's not that difficult. I will be adding support for it to my game emulators. Perhaps I can create a custom IME which connects to this device.

  • GraveUypo

    can you adjust the screen angle or are you stuck with that awkward 45 degrees angle?

    • TwinkieFGR

      That's as far back as it goes, unfortunately.

  • TwinkieFGR

    I just got mine today, it's not perfect, but I'm mostly happy with it.
    But, to be fair, I didn't even order it until AFTER this app existed and was reported to work well.
    After reading a review elsewhere I knew I wasn't touching it if the official software was the only option.
    https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.obsidianx.android.mogaime&feature=nav_other#?t=W251bGwsMSwyLDYsIm5ldC5vYnNpZGlhbnguYW5kcm9pZC5tb2dhaW1lIl0.

  • wewewi

    The iMpulse is going to be sooo much better..

    They even have a stand, now.

  • http://twitter.com/misterE33 Mr E

    this looks cool, but i'm not sure it can beat my $15 used ps3 controller and coathanger-mount

  • carbonated_turtle

    Could they have made it just a little bit bigger? I'm afraid I might actually be able to fit my hands around this thing.

  • gltovar

    lack of dpad is a deal breaker for an controller of this size. I can give an impuse a pass, but this thing has no excuse

  • bitbank

    I've had some more time to play with it now. I like the clamp and the controls are pretty good. The buttons make a little bit too much noise when clicked, but the action is good. The analog nubs are a little stiff and uneven, but get the job done. I actually like the size. Any larger and it wouldn't be as portable. I reverse engineered the bluetooth protocol and it has an odd type of "security". The device needs to be ping'd with a special start code within every 30 seconds or it will hang. This is probably why when you leave the Pivot app, the controller hangs after 30 seconds. I will add support for it to my software.

  • Nix_Nightbird

    There's an unlock app that will allow the Moga to work with most emulators and other games that support Bluetooth controls. Free on the Play store.

  • http://twitter.com/Kihto An Tran

    It's not just software that's problematic. Lack of a d-pad makes it a bit limited in control options and gives the player less buttons for optional controls (like items in Dead Trigger and RPGs). Solved by having players reach up from the controller to touch the button while in intense gamepaly, which is inconvenient. The face buttons are also stiff and can be painful to use for long periods. The analog inputs have the same low travel distance as the Vita's sticks, but instead of being too loose they're too tight.
    It's still usable at least, and I would've forgiven most of those shortcomings if they had at least added a micro-usb port at the bottom of the controller for charging NiMH batteries and for easier connection to a PC. I actually like this stunted little controller, but feel it's not going to have a very long life once more controllers get released this year. A micro-USB port would've increased its value and longevity by a lot for owners of the controller.

  • petesimon2

    Pocket disconnects too often, does not auto reconnect or manually quick reconnect. and then it gets "tired" and goes to sleep or turns off! crap!

  • gamenerd2012

    Know how to fix the sonic cd not redeeming

Quantcast