16
Feb
thumb

The keyboard-packing Droid series is one known to most any smartphone fan. Over the past two years, we've seen the Droid 2, Droid 2 Global, and the Droid 3 all hit the market in an attempt to recreate the popularity of the the original Motorola Droid, all to no avail. All three handsets seemed to just miss the mark - be it lack of 4G or not enough RAM to please enthusiasts and power users.

The latest version of the Droid series, the Droid 4, definitely addresses those issues and more. It's the most powerful Droid that the world has ever seen - but that doesn't necessarily mean it's all good. I've spent the better part of a week with this device and it's time to lay it all on the table - is the Droid 4 the OG Droid reincarnated, or just another QWERTied flop by Motorola?

wm_IMG_1185

At a Glance

The Droid 4 packs some serious improvements over its predecessors, putting it nearly up to par with the current king of the Droid line, the Droid RAZR.

  • 4-inch qHD LCD PenTile display with Gorilla Glass
  • 1.2GHz dual-core OMAP 4430 processor
  • 1GB RAM
  • 16GB internal storage, microSD card slot
  • 8MP rear shooter with 1080p HD video capture
  • 1.3MP 720p HD front-facing camera
  • 802.11 b/g/n Wi-Fi
  • 4G-LTE
  • 179g (6.31oz)
  • 2.8 (w) x 5.0 (h) x 0.5 (d) inches
  • CDMA 800, 1900 EVDO REV A/LTE B13 700
  • 1785 mAh non-removable battery
  • Android 2.3.6 (will be upgraded to Android 4.0)

Sure, it's not too shabby on paper, but how about the execution? Here's a quick look at the good and the bad aspects of the D4.

wm_IMG_1130 wm_IMG_1132

The Good

  • The Keyboard. Let's start with the most obvious thing first. The D4's keyboard is nothing short of fantastic. In fact, it's the best physical QWERTY that I've ever used on a phone.
  • It's solid. Like most other Moto phones, the D4 doesn't fall short in the build quality category. It's solid, well made, and feels like it could take a beating (and survive).
  • Call quality and Reception. Call quality on the Droid 4 is outstanding - everything is crystal clear on both ends. It also consistently has a stronger signal than my Galaxy Nexus, up to 40dBm more in some areas.
  • Battery Life. I've read a lot of kerfuffle surrounding the D4's non-removable battery. If you're concerned that the device will have less-than-satisfactory battery life and you won't be able to replace the battery, don't be. This thing easily runs circles around my Galaxy Nexus.
  • It's Fast. The 1.2GHz OMAP really shines through when using this device - there is virtually no lag whatsoever.
  • LTE. Many, many users have waited for the day a QWERTY-packed Droid hit the market with 4G LTE intact, and it's finally a reality.

The Bad

  • The Display. Again, starting with the most obvious first. This is, without a doubt, the worst display I've ever seen on a modern smartphone. The ghosting is completely intolerable - it's actually almost nauseating, especially with black text on a white background.
  • Android 2.3.6. Don't get me wrong, there's nothing wrong with Gingerbread, but any phone launching in February of '12 should be running Ice Cream Sandwich out of the box. Thankfully, Moto should be rolling out an update... eventually.
  • Bloatware. There is more bloatware on this device than you can shake a stick at. Thirty-one apps to be exact (full list below).
  • Blur. It isn't awful, but it isn't good, either. I think it makes Android look dark, depressing, and dated; Blur is in desperate need of a makeover.

In A Sentence: The Droid 4 packs a fast processor, good battery life, and an excellent keyboard; unfortunately, it also has the worst display that I've ever seen on a smartphone.

You Should Buy It If:  If you just can't live without a physical QWERTY and want some of the latest hardware in a 4G LTE handset, then D4 is probably the best (if not the only) option. However, you'll have to learn to deal with an awful amount of ghosting from the display.

Video Review

Non-removable battery, non-removable battery, non-removable battery!

Build Quality and Physical Keyboard

wm_IMG_1133 wm_IMG_1144

As I said in my initial impressions, this device is built like a tank - it's as solid as you could possibly want a device to be. Because of the keyboard, it does feel a bit bulky in-hand; in terms of size, though, it's actually quite thin given the slide-out QWERTY.

Speaking of, the keyboard on this device is nothing short of wonderful. It's a pleasure to type on, especially for those who are coming from another device with a physical keyboard. The edge-lit keys are a nice touch, making it very easy to type in a dimly-lit or dark room.

However, there are a few things I've found to be amiss with this keyboard. Firstly, there's no dedicated search button. This may not be a big deal to many, but back in the days when the OG Droid was my primary phone, I used the search key on the keyboard all the time. Sure, there's a search key in the capacitive row below the screen, but it's just convenient to have one on the keyboard. Also, the apostrophe is in an unusual position. It's only natural to go to the right side of any keyboard for this particular mark, but on the D4 it's actually on the left side (above the tab key). Again, not a huge deal, but a bit on the annoying side. I'm sure it's probably fine after you get used to it.

One thing that I would like to see incorporated into the keyboard is a spring-loaded mechanism. While sliding the keyboard out isn't difficult by any means, there's just something ever-so satisfying about barely pushing a screen bezel and watching it slide forward like a switchblade, exposing the keyboard.

wm_IMG_1142 wm_IMG_1141

Those minor annoyances aside, however, the keyboard is rock solid and should fit the bill for anyone looking for the best physical keyboard they can get in an Android phone.

Display

This is, without a doubt, the low point of the review. In my initial impressions, I said "I'll say this about the display: it's not awful." Having spent more time with the device, I'll take this opportunity to change my stance on that. This display is awful. The color reproduction isn't what it should be (though it's not as bad as the Droid X2). Still, whites aren't white and greens aren't green - it just doesn't look right. Then there's the issue of pixelation. It's very noticeable in the 3G icon, signal strength indicator, and battery icon in the navigation bar. It's actually akin to that of the X2; perhaps just a tad bit better.

wm_IMG_1192 wm_IMG_1194

While both of the aforementioned issues are tolerable, the primary problem with the D4's display is ghosting. The X2 had similar problems, as did the Bionic. But, after comparing the displays on all three devices, both of those devices pale in comparison to the Droid 4. I'm not being pretentious, either - it's honestly that bad. The ghosting is enough to make anyone nauseated, especially when it's black text on a white background (read: the settings menu, many web pages, Facebook, Google +... you get the idea). It's a bit less noticeable with a dark background and light text, but it's still there. It's especially bad while slowly scrolling, so trying to skim over text is almost a no-go. While it's still present when quickly scrolling, it's not as noticeable since you're not actually trying to read the words. For a better idea of what I'm talking about, take a look at the video review.

Fortunately, the problem is really only evident while scrolling, so videos and games are largely unaffected.

With all of that said, some users may really not find the ghosting a huge deal. I, however, definitely did. My suggestion? Head over the local VZW store and give it a shot for yourself, but pay special attention to any scenario where you're looking at black text on a white background. You may find that you hate it as much as I do; on the other hand, you may find it tolerable.

Battery Life

wm_IMG_1137 wm_IMG_1136 wm_IMG_1138

As bad as the display is, it does bring one major selling point to the table: better battery life. When it comes to good battery life, the D4 has it in spades. I was able to use the device as my primary phone and easily make it through an entire day. That's playing music, a bit of surfing the web, playing games (Zenonia 4, to be exact), checking the social sites, and, of course, phone calls/texting.

device-2012-02-15-103315 device-2012-02-15-103454

The above screenshot was taken with about two hours of display time and 30(ish) minutes of talk time, all without changing the default mobile network from CDMA/LTE. In short, I was seriously blown away by the D4's battery life - it could easily double that of my Galaxy Nexus. Thus, for anyone concerned with the non-removable battery - don't be.

Software and Performance

I can sum the software up in one word: bloatware. Oh, and Blur, I guess. So, two words. While the latter isn't as important (because, let's face it - Blur is Blur is Blur, right?) the former is completely absurd. Here's a glimpse into what the four pages of apps hold right out of the box:

  1. Amazon Kindle
  2. Apps (VZW)
  3. Blockbuster
  4. Device Setup
  5. GoToMeeting
  6. Guided Tours
  7. Help Center
  8. IM
  9. Let's Golf 2
  10. Madden 12
  11. Mobile Hotspot
  12. MOG Music
  13. MOTOACTV
  14. MOTOPRINT
  15. My Accounts
  16. My Files (this one is actually useful)
  17. My Verizon
  18. Netflix
  19. NFL Mobile
  20. Quickoffice
  21. Slacker Radio
  22. Slingbox
  23. Smart Actions
  24. Social Location
  25. Social Networking
  26. Task Manager
  27. Tasks
  28. V Cast Tones
  29. Verizon Video
  30. VerizonSurf
  31. VZ Navigator

device-2012-02-15-154337 device-2012-02-15-154607 device-2012-02-15-154617 device-2012-02-15-154625

Yeah, 31 bloatware apps. Granted, some of those are Blur apps (about nine), but all the rest are VZW pre-loaded, uninstallable crap. Now we know how they got the price down to $199 with a two-year agreement. They subsidized the other $100 with more unwanted apps than any one person wants. Pathetic.

Despite the voluminous amount of bloatware plaguing the D4 out of the box, it still manages to run like a top. Thanks largely to its 1.2GHz OMAP processor, the Droid 4 consistently scored 2000+ in Quadrant (which is now optimized for multiple cores),  while Linpack pushed out a reasonable 44 .xx most of the time. Of course, benchmarks only paint part of the picture. Throughout my duration with the D4, I experienced no lag, slowdowns, or performance hits of any kind. Navigating between apps is snappy and responsive.

So, in a nutshell, there's too much bloatware, but it still performs wonderfully.

Camera

This is yet another area in which I was impressed with the D4's performance. Honestly, I didn't expect much from the camera, so when I saw the images it produced, I was pleasantly surprised.

2012-02-16_14-23-02_374 2012-02-16_14-24-09_378

2012-02-16_14-05-59_307 2012-02-16_14-03-08_22

2012-02-16_14-01-08_335 

I've grown quite used to the instant response time of the camera on my Galaxy Nexus, so I'm pleased to say that the response time on the Droid 4 is almost just as fast.

Motorola has made some nice improvements to the stock camera software, as well. It can automatically apply specific effects to the images, such as sepia tones, various color tints, black and white, negative, and solarize. It also has a variety of scenes to choose from for taking specific pictures, including portrait, landscape, sport, night, sunset, macro, and low light - most of which I only wish my Nexus had.

device-2012-02-16-151531 device-2012-02-16-151541 device-2012-02-16-151550 device-2012-02-16-151602

It can also take panoramic photos, though the process is a bit on the cumbersome side. It's not as fluid as the default panoramic setting in Ice Cream Sandwich, but it's not as choppy as using something like Pano - it's somewhere in between the two. Aside from panoramic mode, it also has a really nice feature for taking several shots all in a row called mult-shot, which could come in handy for taking pictures at sporting events or the like.

2012-02-16_14-07-58_593

Video Sample

The D4 can record video in 1080p, and it does a pretty decent job at it.

Wft are they doing?

Call Quality and Reception

2012-02-15 20.29.51

Like most other Motorola phones, the call quality is absolutely outstanding. The speaker is loud and crystal clear, and the mic is equally as excellent. In terms of using the D4 as a phone, you won't find a better solution anywhere.

Also like other Moto phones, it pulls in signal like a pro. While my Galaxy Nexus is sitting idly at -100 dBm, the Droid 4 has a modest signal stregth of -86dBm. That's not a one-time thing, either - those results were pretty consistent regardless of where I went, and often times even better.

Conclusion

wm_IMG_1135

So, how does the Droid 4 stack up against the keyboard-packing Droids of old? It has a substantially better keyboard, a processor that packs a punch, and enough juice to get you through the day. It may not have the same impact on the market or the Android world that the OG Droid had, but, despite its less-than-spectacular screen, it's definitely the best Droid since the old fella retired.

If a keyboard, LTE, and good battery life are on your must-have list for a new device, then the Droid 4 is probably the best option out there. Unfortunately, you'll have to deal with a shoddy display and a crap-ton of bloatware (before you say it - I know that you can "root and remove" the crapware, but that's not a viable option for everyone) to get what you're after. If it sounds like a worthy trade-off to you, then I say go for it. If not, however, then there are much better solutions on the market right now.

Cameron Summerson
Cameron is a self-made geek, Android enthusiast, horror movie fanatic, musician, and cyclist. When he's not pounding keys here at AP, you can find him spending time with his wife and kids, plucking away on the 6-string, spinning on the streets, or watching The Texas Chainsaw Massacre on repeat.

  • ocdtrekkie

    What I don't understand about the Verizon bloatware craze, is how niche they are. Many of them are subscription-only affairs like Blockbuster and Netflix, and MOTOACTV, we realistically know the vast majority of Droid owners aren't going to buy that device. If they are apps that you can use out of the box, fine, throw a couple bloats on there, but a lot of these you actually *can't use* right off for *anything*.

  • http://www.AndroidPolice.com Artem Russakovskii

    It's 2012, and yet Motorola manages to ship devices with screens that are not only worse than its competitors but worse than even its own devices in the past.

    It's a shame something so good can be completely ruined by the screen in this day and age.

    • Jon

      I want to ahve a talk with the guy who chose such a crappy screen to use. Oh, then give him a piece of my mind.

    • duplissi

      pentile really isnt that bad, a qhd pentile is defintely better than a standare wvga screen which some phones are still shipping with.

      people really need to stop the dramatics.

    • xploited

      Artem, why the persistent hate on the Moto screens?

      I still have an Atrix and seen many many other phones' screens.
      I can honestly say that pentile qHD looks better than wvga, like the one on SGSII.

      Motorola's pentile does have some drawbacks - color reproduction.
      But it has advanteages too - easier on the battery and better brightness.

      The "visible crosshatch" and "ghosting" problems are either made up or screen-specific. As I haven't seen any of these on my screen.

      Having said that, a better screen would be one of the last reasons for me to upgrade the phone.

      It isn't nearly as bad as people say.

      • drksilenc

        are you trolling xploited or what the samoled screen blow the doors of off any screen moto has used in a phone. in bot color accuracy resolution and usablity in light

  • Mark

    The Droid keyboard phones are dying a slow and painful death. This might be the final nail in the coffin. I'm sure Verizon thinks otherwise though...

    • http://www.androidpolice.com David Ruddock

      Verizon couldn't care less - the name is alive and well with other non-QWERTY products. If sales suck, they won't hesitate to dump it.

  • sriracha

    you earn seven interwebs for working "kerfuffle" into your review, Cameron. great review!

  • Carlos

    I own a Droid 3 and even when I acknowledge that there are better displays for me pentile LCD is no problem at all.
    Also we don't have LTE in Mexico, so for me there is absolutely no reason to upgrade other than that extra 512 MB RAM. Still I'm yet to have a better experience typing in a virtual keyboard than in my beloved physical qwerty. I really hope that the option never disappear.

  • Tyler C

    the bloatware that came on my Thunderbolt was one of the sole reasons I rooted it within the first week.
    The Verizon rep told me "oh and this is how you uninstall apps etc" SO naturally trying to uninstall the terrible bloatware was the first thing I attempted to no avail. I remember I had about 12 or so apps I flat out wanted nothing to do with.

  • me

    my galaxy nexus got 1d 16hrs of battery life yesterday :) granted i didnt use it that much during the time but still. much better than my og droid and thunderbolt

  • Deon

    A custom ROM can solve the bloatware and blur issue. I'm not to worried about that, the hardware to me is more important. I'm a bit dismayed at the screen though. I need to recommend an Android phone to a client who uses Blackberry (but understands he has to switch as his blackberry is really dated). He's a big email person. So a keyboard is important to him. Do you think the screen is a big enough deal for me not to recommend this phone?

    • drksilenc

      locked firmware means no custom roms...

      • parineum

        It means no custom kernels.

  • Josh

    Ugh, the screens are one of the biggest reasons I chose to go with an HTC instead of another Motorola when I finally upgraded from my OG Droid. And I too hate the Verizon bloatware!

  • Alex Kidd

    This reviewer raves about battery life. No wonder, every single screenshot, he's under 3G coverage. Kick on the 4G LTE radio and see how long it lasts.

    • Cameron Summerson

      While I may not have 4G where I live, I didn't disable the 4G radio the entire time I had the device. I'm convinced that, even in a 4G LTE area, the battery would still last a full day.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608855720 Debbie Baldwin

        Nope, doesnt last a full day at all..not until i got the advanced kill apps app.

  • jeremy

    this thing is an ugly brick... would never buy a Moto phone until they have better screens and design. geez....

  • Steve

    So glad I have a beautiful screen on my Stratosphere. :-)

    • Reyas

      You won't be for long, I just finally dumped mine and its frickin needing to be replaced THREE TIMES IN ONE WEEK.

  • Max

    How does the screen compare to the droid 1 screen?

  • Julian S.

    I just got my Droid 4 to replace my X2. I agree that the screen is nowhere near what other phones are offering, but this phone is lightning fast! I feel that its speed completely makes up for its lack in the screen department. When this phone is running on 4G it is truly amazing! This phone is many times better than my X2.

  • Reyas

    ARGH! I just got this phone today, and after several hours of charging, it has a five minute battery life. LONG BATTERY MY FRICKIN ASS!

  • dale nicholson

    I was granted a early upgrade due to major issues with my LG ALLY..!! I chose the Motorola droid 4 this was all final in march of 2012 here it is October 2012... I am on my 6th DROID 4 replacement due to speaker failure ... I am totally disgusted with this fact there is a major design flaw with the DROID 4..!!!!!!! Looks like I am stuck with another''LEMON'' through Verizion's 2yr contract...!!!!

  • elishakay

    droid 4 locked up will turn on and off but touch screen will not work and its totally locked up after soft boot